I absolutely love the video game portraits! This should become a parody game portraying art communities as a fantasy setting. Perhaps with a little MediEvil style darkness thrown into the setting - it does seem like it'd fit very well.
Let's see. I'd say I'm primarily the Primal, but I also have mellower versions of Catboy, Knight, Automata, and the Arcane, Power, and Aether Enchanters mixed in. What I mean about those last three is that I almost always comment on specific things about the art, but give encouragement as a rule, and perhaps also rate things higher than I should. I also have a bad habit of doomscrolling and using creativity as a means to vent about the awful things I see. Only reason I wouldn't also be Entropy Enchanter is because I've trained myself to revise my posts and cut out self-deprecation in them before submitting.
Good job - I definitely find this much more relatable than other archetype memes I've seen elsewhere. I have a friend who was the subject of a Clown prank and have known an Alien who legitimately had aphantasia (can't create mental images), so those two especially hit home for me. This was fun to look at!